Monkberry Moon's Not Right
Anybody out there like Monk? Not the fish, nor the order--the hit USA TV show starring Tony Shaloub. If you've been a fan, and notice I say "if," you've witnessed, as have I, a show that always seems to be in flux. Is it an out and out comedy? No wait, let's be a bit more serious than that and leaven the proceedings with humor. No wait, let's go back to the wacky comedy. Hey, let's give the characters some humanity. No, that's too much. Let's make them do things they would never do. That will get them watching.
It seems the people running this show simply can not make up their minds how they want the characters to act. One minute, Monk is a brilliant detective, very humane and astute; the next, he's a mindless idiot who doesn't have a clue that three-card-monte isn't a legitimate game.
And now, they've gone and upset the apple cart big time--they've gotten rid of the character of Sharona, Monk's "nurse," who acts more like his assistant, sometimes helping to solve crimes that Monk is working on. The creators have decided to go in another direction, and are casting for a thirty-something woman who, I believe, will be working in a bar. Yeah, that sounds like the right direction. Monk can hang around the bar and solve the case of the missing fifth.
Shaloub is a gifted actor, with terrific comic instincts, but he is increasingly poorly served by the scripts here. And he only has himself to blame, at least partially--he is a producer of the show.
The next batch of new episodes bows in January; hopefully, they will have worked out the kinks and bring the show back to its original glories.
Don't miss this weekend's USA Today. The Life section has a guide to the new fall shows; I'm really looking forward to J.J. "Alias, not Felicity" Abrams' Lost (40-something folks gets stranded on an island with a monster and who knows what else). I'm sort of looking forward to what will probably be the last season of NYPD Blue. I'm a longtime fan, and although it's not what it used to be--especially as it was in the Jimmy Smits days--it's still pretty solid. I'm looking forward to the sixth season of the West Wing, only out of curiousity. I'll have more on the new fall shows in a future post.
Back later.
